Skip to main content
Nutrition Science4 min read

Why do diets fail?

Diets fall apart in the days after a big day of eating, when you try to make up for it and start again. Eat your next meal as if nothing happened.

One Saturday I ate 4,300 calories.

Deliberately.

As of that very morning, I'd lost 5kg from 10 weeks of work.

I decided to see what would happen to my weight.

...imagine if that was you.

The day after overeating, what happens for you?

I stepped on the scales and I was up 2kg... how would you react?

Here's what I've done in the past:

  • "Fuck it." I find every food I've been restricting and decide to take advantage of the binge.
  • "I need to fix this." I plan to restart the next day, which triggers more eating the night before.
  • I cut calories the next day, end up too hungry and still feel guilty, so I decide to eat more.
  • I weigh myself to see the "damage" and then have to spend the next week trying to make up for it.
  • I feel like I've wasted a whole week of work and gone backwards because of a single day.
  • It makes the whole thing feel too hard if I can do that much "damage" that quickly.
  • I can't seem to get consistent again after that, maybe for a week or two, but then another binge happens.
  • I decide maybe it's not the right time, I need something different or new (cue googling how to lose weight for the millionth time) and start making new grand plans to lose weight.
  • In the meantime, I decide it would be best if I just relax with food and "take a break from it"... code for eat whatever I want for a while.
  • Eventually I start a new diet and lose weight in the first week because I binged the weekend before starting the diet.

You can have a big day of eating and feel huge the next day. But, most of that jump on the scales is food and water, not fat. What often happens is you feel awful, so you go on a spiral for a couple of weeks. That's where most of the weight gain actually happens.

Now we know:

  • It's a single day or a single meal, it's insignificant.
  • I just ate more than normal, it doesn't justify beating myself up nor does it justify eating more.
  • In fact, making a healthy meal for dinner or for breakfast the next day makes me feel a lot better. I might not like myself but I can respect myself.
  • I didn't waste a week, the timeline I have set in my head is arbitrary and I'm ok with getting the same results just a week later.
  • I have so many more opportunities to get it right.

Negative thoughts were still appearing. I felt bloated, so I didn't feel as good in my body.

There was definitely a sense of "it's ruined", like my brand new toy just got a scratch on it.

Suddenly, I was 5 years old again.

Those thoughts and feelings don't just disappear. I just know how to deal with that voice a lot better. I know how to talk back.

And, more importantly, I know how I want to keep showing up (in spite of whatever I may have done in the past).

"Just keep swimming," says the new voice in my head.

That's my coach voice.

So, if you've had a big day, eat your next meal as if nothing happened, then string together three normal days of eating.

Maybe you'll find your own coach voice (or you can borrow mine).

PS. If bingeing or making up for it feels out of your control, talk to your GP or call the Butterfly Foundation on 1800 33 4673, even if it doesn't feel "big enough" yet.

Did this help?

Your answer helps us improve these articles.

Work out your numbers

Try the macro calculator