Skip to main content
Nutrition Science4 min read

Can I track my food and still eat intuitively?

Yes. Track for a few weeks to learn your portions, then step away from tracking one day at a time, starting with a Tuesday.

Most people who've tracked for a long time are scared to eat intuitively.

The reality is, you can do both. I'd argue you probably want the skill to track and then step away from tracking.

I'd argue that maybe once a year, you want to do a short period of tracking, just to realign your eyeballs with the portions that are right for you and figure out what calories you're eating right now.

As we've all probably experienced, what gets measured gets managed.

Tracking is kind of like putting the guards up at the bowling alley, right?

The longer you go without tracking, the lower the guardrails get.

I tracked for 5-6 years non-stop.

I was terrified to stop. I couldn't even get past a month the first time.

But, I eventually became more comfortable with it.

And, something you might be surprised that I promote...

I take long hiatuses from tracking.

Where do I start?

If you want to try it, start tracking your food WITHOUT TARGETS for 2-3 weeks.

You keep eating intuitively and simply bring awareness to what you're eating.

I just take photos and let Healthly do the rest.

Then bring in targets that are very flexible.

I only look at calories and keep my protein up, and I only care about my weekly average.

I want you to make sure you still let your appetite guide you. Don't eat more just because the app tells you to, and don't stop yourself eating when you're really effing hungry.

How do I step away from tracking?

Don't go from tracking every single day to not tracking at all.

Here's the way I recommend doing it:

  1. Pick one really standard day, like a Tuesday, when you eat the same foods every week. Make that the day you don't track.
  2. Eventually do another day, two days apart or two in a row.
  3. Then test a weekend day, like a Saturday. Eat the way you would on a tracked day, you just don't get to see the numbers.
  4. Then all five weekdays, then a whole week with the weekend, and then you're not tracking anymore.

Don't start with a weekend or a holiday. It can feel like anarchy without any constraints all of a sudden.

If that still feels scary, this worked really well for me.

I wrote out a day of my stereotypical meals and snacks, at exactly the calories I needed:

  • 180g of chicken or beef, or 150g of salmon
  • 250g of potato, 80g of pasta or a cup of rice
  • a bunch of veggies with a teaspoon of olive oil
  • my coffee, which I count as a snack because it has milk in it
  • an apple or a capsicum, a piece of dark chocolate and a protein shake or bar

I put it on my fridge and it essentially became my meal plan. I'd just rinse and repeat.

That was years ago, and I still remember the quantities.

I can do them roughly by eye every time I cook.

Should I be able to keep chocolate in the house?

I do believe you can get to a point where you keep foods in the house and don't freak out about them.

Here's the catch: even when you're eating intuitively, you still practise healthy constraints.

I know my intuition would eat chocolate and pizza every day if it could.

If it works not keeping it in the house, then don't keep it in the house. That doesn't mean you never have it again.

There's a great book, it's like the encyclopaedia of intuitive eating, called Intuitive Eating, by Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch. Their version starts with rejecting diets altogether. I'm a bit different. If you've got a goal like leaning out, I believe you need a few more constraints around food.

How do I know if I'm hungry?

Relearning your hunger and fullness signals is a process.

And, it's the best part about intuitive eating.

They aren't always what you think they are.

When I'm hungry, I get impatient and lose my ability to focus. A rumbly tummy doesn't happen that often for me.

When I'm full, I can often still eat. But, I've learnt that satisfied and stuffed are two different things.

So, if you're tracking right now, pick your Tuesday this week. No real changes, except you don't look at the numbers.

Unless you're planning to track until the day you die, you need to know how to not track.

PS. If you've had an eating disorder, or you're bingeing, cutting right back or checking the numbers all day right now, call the Butterfly Foundation on 1800 33 4673 before you try any of this.

Did this help?

Your answer helps us improve these articles.

Work out your numbers

Try the macro calculator