Consistency, calories and protein are the most important things when it comes to fat loss.
Meal timing, supplements and meal frequency are at best little things that can make you feel fully committed but at worst things that can become totally overwhelming and completely derail you.
People who fast lose about the same as people who just eat less every day, whether it's 16:8, 5:2 or fasting every second day.
So, if fasting makes it easier for you to eat less across the week, go for it.
If it has you starving by dinner, it's not the one for you.
Will I get enough protein?
Say you don't start eating till 9 or 10am and then you stop eating around 6 or 7.
It might be harder to get in enough protein, because you've got a shorter window of time to get it in.
If you start eating your protein earlier in the day and have another serve, boom, you're already 25-30g ahead for the day.
Can you work out fasted (aka no food)?
Yes but, like me, there's a chance your performance and recovery won't be as good. It also depends on the intensity of the session, your current energy stores and how long the session is.
In a cut, I often train on just a flat white, so I'm close to fasted.
It's under 200 calories and has 12g carbs.
But this SUCKS for performance. Especially as I drink decaf.
So what do I do?
On my harder training days, I add starchy carbs:
- Half a bagel
- Tortilla
- Rice cake
- Maple syrup
But, just a flat white on more chill training days suits me, as I don't feel hungry. I'm ok if my training session is compromised because the goal is fat loss not performance.
Think of it like this...
The shorter and more intense it is, the more your body prefers carbs.
The longer and less intense it is, the more your body prefers fats (ps fasted or fed, it makes no real difference to how much fat you lose).
What if I'm starving by dinner?
A little bit of hunger before a meal is fine, but starving before a meal is a recipe for over eating, because control goes out the window when you're over hungry.
Over hunger = over desire = over eating = over restriction = the cycle begins again.
This week, track what you eat and look at the pattern across your meals:
- When you eat less protein at breakfast, does that mean you need a protein shake in the afternoon to hit your target?
- When you skip lunch, does that mean you go way above your calories at dinner?
This helps you diagnose the problem. When you can see the pattern, you can proactively intercept it and get a different outcome.
PS. If you're under 18, pregnant, breastfeeding, have had an eating disorder or take diabetes medication or a medicine you have to have with food, don't fast without talking to your GP first, and if skipping meals has you bingeing at night, call the Butterfly Foundation on 1800 33 4673.
Did this help?
Your answer helps us improve these articles.